These questions were answered by
Victor: Well, let’s just say it’s most certainly not easy. As with any top school, there is strong competition, and there will be many brilliant students competing for a spot. In a typical year there could be anything from 100-200 applications, and 10-15 offers are made. It would generally be wise to apply to other schools also.
Victor: I think it is definitely important. It’s where you give a taste of your personality. Most of your application is numbers and ratings. And believe me, most of the people that apply here will be as good. This is where you have the opportunity to stand out.
Ani: We’re the specialists at getting information out of numbers! Your statement of purpose is important, but so are your transcript, rec letters etc.
Victor: I would think that the GRE results are a necessary but not sufficient condition for admittance. A top grade is expected in maths, and a good grade in the verbal test, although emphasis would probably be given to the former rather than the latter.
Victor: On the contrary, you are not expected to know precisely what you want to do. The first year involves some coursework that will get you to see different areas (along with seminars and conversations with faculty) so that you make a decision sometime in your second year. In fact, Berkeley’s faculty has quite diverse research interests, so that if you’re not sure what you want to do, Berkeley offers many choices.
Victor: Well, I haven’t been through any of the other programs, but my colleagues and myself have found it challenging. I guess that this would also be true for the other top class programs -that’s what makes them top-class programs in the first place!
James: Most students in the department find the core PhD courses - 205, 210, and 215 - quite challenging. Especially 205. Taking a look through the books for these courses and judging your own familiarity with the material may help in assessing how much work you will have to put into these courses. Often faculty members who have taught these courses have syllabi from previous years on their websites.
Victor: The program is very strong in this respect. It has very close ties with computer science, biology (genetics, biostatistics, bioinformatics) and communications (and neuroscience and finance –ed.) In fact there exist “designated emphasis” programs for bioinformatics and communications. In addition, collaboration with scientists from other fields comes individually, through your advisor. For example, I am working in a problem arising from biophysics. I know that people work on topics from various different disciplines, including the above, but also the social sciences (e.g. political science, law). This is a very strong point for Berkeley: almost all of its graduate programs are ranked among the top ten in the country, so that one really works with the cream when collaborating with other departments.
James: My advisors are John Rice and Noureddine El Karoui in the statistics department. We are working on classification problems arising from astronomy data. We work closely with Josh Bloom in the Astro department. In fact, Josh’s lab is located on the fourth floor of Evans Hall, adjacent to the statistics department.
Victor: As you might probably know, Berkeley has been a powerhouse of mathematical/theoretical statistics and has a very strong tradition there. However it is not the case that Berkeley is “all” theory: Berkeley does “everything”, but expects you to know your theory well. As my advisor (David Brillinger) says: theory becomes practice.
Victor: In theory the course is a 4-year course, although most students take 5 years. This will certainly depend on how soon one decides their preferred area for specialization and accordingly choose an advisor. It is certainly realistic to aim for four years, and in certain cases some students have completed the program in 3 years.
James: Well I’m finishing up in five years. I would say that’s about average. The average is lower for people who have a masters coming into the program. Usually students get a better idea of when they will graduate as they get further along in the program.
Victor: The department is one of the most historic departments in the country with a long tradition of excellence, and considered an elite center for probability and statistics. Of course it has some special characteristics, placing considerable emphasis on probability theory and theoretical statistics, consequently expecting a strong mathematical background from prospective students.
James: In 2010, U.S. News and World Report ranked Berkeley’s Statistics Department second in the US. Also in 2010, The Chronicle of Higher Education ranked Berkeley Statistics fourth in the country.
Victor: The culture of the program is, I think, that you basically get a firm background during the first one to two years (during which the program is more structured) and then you get into research and things become much looser. The faculty interacts with the students through seminars and classes (this is the “organized interaction”), although I have found the “unorganized interaction” to be much more important: whatever door you knock, the professor will always be willing to hear about your problem - whatever that may be, personal or scientific- and help as much as they can. This is especially important when you do research, since you have access to people with a very wide variety of research interests.
Victor: I think it’s best to visit the different places you have offers from. This will give you a feeling of the atmosphere there. My visit to Berkeley was crucial for my decision to join the program.
Victor: An important thing about the department is the wide range of faculty research interests. This is naturally reflected in the students, who work on a wide spectrum of topics, ranging from probability as pure math to computational statistics and machine learning. There is also a lot of interdisciplinary activity going on (I am an example of it) especially in the areas of biology (here I include biostatistics, statistical genetics, bioinformatics) and electrical engineering/computer science. I think the department is trying to promote collaboration with people form other departments, and it is actually possible to be co-advised from someone in another department.
Victor: My impression is that the atmosphere in the department is very informal and quite friendly. From my experience all faculty members are happy to discuss with graduate students and give advice. As for how much help your advisor provides, that depends on the individual. There are professors that will monitor your work closely, and others that will expect you to be more independent. Whatever your preference may be, I expect that there are plenty of people on both sides!
Victor: Yes, any student admitted to the Ph.D. program receives funding at a level comparable to the rest of the top ranked programs. Students typically do a combination of teaching and research assistantships in return.
Victor: There is no general rule here, in that it depends on the “year”! Certain times the incoming students where very social, other times not so much. The students are not very coherent as a group (since there’s around 50 of us it could not be otherwise), and you will find that they are connected usually more with people from their own year (maybe plus or minus one) or with people with similar research interests. This has also been my experience.
James: There are a lot of opportunities for social interaction among graduate students. For the past few years the statistics department has had intramural soccer and Ultimate frisbee teams in the Berkeley IM League. We play teams of other Berkeley students. There is a statistics department sports mailing list for organizing these teams as well as casual practices. Most Fridays graduate students organize a “Friday Wind Down” where we head to a local pub / restaurant. Typically non-stats friends and members of the biostats department come along as well. In terms of major parties, there is an annual “Kansas Party”, held in the Spring each semester. This is one of the highlights of the stats social season.
Victor: I find it very pleasant. People are easy-going, it is relatively safe, and the weather is mild throughout the year. San Francisco is only half an hour away (and you get a free bus ride back and forth with your student ID!!).
James: As a student you are a resident of Berkeley and the Bay Area, which means Oakland and San Francisco are next door. I had a great time living in the Rockridge section of Oakland a few years ago. It was a 15 minute (free) bus commute to campus, so no problem getting to work and the social life in Rockridge was awesome. Now I live in a COOP that is part of the Berkeley Student Cooperative (BSC) . It’s a very fun, and very Berkeley, lifestyle.
Victor: I don’t know much about the masters programs, because I did not do one myself. I should think that the differences are minor academically, although you should note that the masters degree in the US usually is a year and a half to two years long (while in the UK it’s a one-year program). The Ph.D. programs are quite different though. In the UK you start straight away doing research, usually having selected an advisor when applying. The emphasis is completely on research. This is excellent when you know what you want to do, and have a clear idea about whom you want to work with. In the US there usually is a first year of intense graduate coursework to build a stronger background. At the end of that year there is usually an exam you have to pass, and after that you start looking for an advisor (at Berkeley they did away with this exam in 2005, and instead progress is monitored through the coursework). Sometimes you have to take courses even in your second year (although in a much more relaxed way). The first year tends to be very intense. One thing to take in mind is that in the UK it is harder to go straight into a Ph.D. program without a masters degree, although in the US this is more common.
Victor: My impression is that in general in the US, statistics departments tend to be more mathematical. In several places statistics is considered part of mathematics, and so there is quite some emphasis placed on the mathematics of it.
Victor: To be frank I don’t know that much about the masters program. However this opinion may have some merit, in the sense that the course Ph.D. in the US involves a lot of coursework anyway, so that a masters degree may have a more professional profile to it, hence larger demand from within the US.
Ani: For foreign students it’s particularly hard to be admitted, whether for Masters or for PhD. It’s not true that there’s more US demand for the Master’s degree. Most of the applications are non-US. The acceptance rate is about 1 in 10 for both programs.
Victor: There is no general rule. Obviously this depends on the applicant. What I do know is that at some point in the application for the Ph.D. degree, you can state that you would like to be considered for the M.A. in case they cannot offer you a place in the Ph.D. program.